My husband and I dove with Stuart Cove over three days. Their service, equipment and hospitality were above average compared with other dive shops we've been to (Hawaii, Grand Cayman and Toronto). The first day was a 2-tank AM dive at DC-3 (where "Into the Blue" was filmed) and Elkhorn Garden. We hired a private DM, "Spike" and he was awesome. He made us feel comfortable and confident (since it's been a year since we last dove). It was a beautiful day with small waves. Spike directed our attention to different wildlife at each of the sites and answered all our questions to the best of his knowledge.
On the second day, we completed our Shark Awareness course in the afternoon. There were other divers on the Phoecena who were there for the shark dive. Our first dive was at Shark Wall, which was near Shark Arena (for the feeding). It was a free swim to see the grey Caribbean reef sharks in their natural habitat. Johran our lead and captain briefed us on our first dive. We were to descend to the feed area, then proceed to the wall. I was amazed at the number of sharks just checking us out when I jumped in! They were everywhere! It was so serene to see them cruising along. I guess I was supposed to get an adrenaline rush, but that was not the case. A giant black grouper emerged from the nearby coral as the divers entered the water and met at the feed site. Pictures were taken as some divers stroked him like a puppy! Once we were all together, Johran led us to the wall where we saw lionfish (which are somewhat a parasite since they are not indigenous to the area and have no natural predators) and the regulars. After our surface interval, we were briefed on our second dive - the feed. Basically, keep your arms to yourself, don't wave at the camera, and don’t try to stay upright if you find yourself tipping over. Johran told us that once everyone was settled in the semi-circle, he'd descend with the bait box. It seemed like the sharks knew they were going to get a snack because once he jumped in, they all circled until he settled on the sandy bottom. Then the feeding began, not a frenzy like what you see on the Discovery Channel, but it was exciting nonetheless. Johran brought the bait box close to us so that the photographer could get great shots of the sharks circling and charging for the fish heads. I was saddened to see some of the sharks with hooks still lodged in their mouths from long line fishing! After about a 20min feeding session, we got the chance (once the sharks left the area) to search for shark teeth! We were the only ones to find teeth (it was like sifting for gold)... In the sand there were bits of rock or shells and everything looked the same.
Originally we had booked only 2 dive days, but we decided to do one last dive. On our third day, we did the 2-tank PM dive. This time, our departure was later and we had less time since we had to wait for the cruise ship people (this was a Tuesday) and also get them back to port on-time. This kinda sucked since we couldn't go very far then and had a limited choice in sites. I heard there was a site with skeletons but it was too far away. We ended up going to David Tucker and Nari Nari (from Jaws 4). These were easy-going dives but we had Spike with us again since we didn't know the area. Once again he led us on a great dive. On the last dive, he brought dog food and yellow-tailed snapper rushed to get their share of the food. They tore the Ziploc bag apart! We got great pictures with them swirling around.
Some of the fish we saw over the three days were:
snapper, grouper (black, tiger), angelfish (queen, grey, French), French grunt, nudibranch, Christmas tree worms, other sea slug (with horns?), lionfish, sharks, jellyfish, gobies, squirrelfish, parrotfish, wrasses, fairy basslets, bicolour damselfish, sergeant majors, blue chromis, blue tangs, horse-eye jacks, trunkfish, trumpetfish, chubs and the list goes on!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.